Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> We should not have models that are willing to build you a contagious disease, or a self-propagating worm.

Why?

 help



Because we don't want people creating contagious diseases and self-propagating worms. And, because we don't want models that will do so without even having been told to, because that furthers one of its goals or subgoals.

The same things could be done by you or me using the internet or books though, why does the model make it different? If it's speed of iteration, imagine we had a machine that surfaced any piece of knowledge the human race had ever recorded with just a thought, but the human had to write the worm or disease by hand – is it still the model that's the problem, or the knowledge itself?

> And, because we don't want models that will do so without even having been told to, because that furthers one of its goals or subgoals.

Ignoring the fact that you'd need some kind of lab with biological material to create a contagious disease, what kind of prompt are we writing where a model accidentally creates a contagious disease or self-propagating worm as one of its goals?


> The same things could be done by you or me using the internet or books though, why does the model make it different?

Imagine two worlds. In one world, everyone has a button that ends the world, which is badly labeled and may also press itself at any time. In another, people who have gone through a substantial amount of effort and dedication to learn something extremely difficult, also understand that they could apply that knowledge towards bad ends. Which world exists for longer?

> what kind of prompt are we writing where a model accidentally creates a contagious disease or self-propagating worm as one of its goals?

Given a sufficiently powerful model? Any prompt that could be done better by seizing additional computing power, or preventing the operators from turning it off. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instrumental_convergence




Consider applying for YC's Fall 2026 batch! Applications are open till July 27.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: